The Blue Box Blog

Emma Lou's adventures in Doctor Who fandom

Top Ten: 10 Mad Fan Theories (That Might Actually Be True)

Posted by emmahyam on December 9, 2011

Doctor Who has been with us now for 48 years and naturally in a show with such a long run somethings just don’t make sense. With thousands of hours of televised adventures, hundreds of novels and audio plays, some considered canonical, some not. Some events enshrined into accepted continuity and then retconned back out, some gaps will appear or indeed things that the fans plain just don’t like will be enforced by the producers. Where they do fan theories will step in to fill the holes, here are my top ten favourites, of course your mileage will vary about how convincing they are, as always please read with caution as there be SPOILERS below…

10) The “Five Peri’s” Theory.

After the revelation of Peri’s fate in “Trial of a Timelord” what subsequently happens to her has become somewhat of a mystery with various novels and audio plays either trying to entirely retcon the bizarre decision to marry her off to Yrcanos or have her leave him and somehow get back to Earth. The recent audio play “Peri and the Piscon Paradox” has proposed the idea that there are no fewer than five versions of poor old Peri in existence due to the Time Lords interference in her personal time line, one who was killed in “Mindwarp”, one who married Yrcanos, an older version who only remembers the events of “Planet of Fire” and two others of which nothing is known.

9) The War Chief is a prior regeneration of the Master.

The War Chief is a powerful renegade Time Lord, during the events of “The War Games” he conspires with a very powerful alien race bringing his knowledge of time travel and hypnosis to the table, sound familiar? In terms of personality The War Chief certainly could be the Master, hes arrogant, ambitious, lusts for power and exhibits a fondness for elaborate facial hair. The idea that The War Chief is in fact an earlier incarnation of the Master certainly hold some weight on this basis, the idea first came about when “The Doctor Who Role Playing Game” claimed that The Meddling Monk, The War Chief and The Master were all different incarnations of the same Time Lord. This idea has been accepted as unofficial canon and then contradicted in equal measure with some novels using it as an established fact and some directly stating that this is not the case.

8 ) The Doctor was being metaphorical when he said he was half-human.

This idea originated in fan circles in reaction to the Eighth Doctor’s statement that he was “half human on his mothers side” in the TV Movie. The TV Movie aka “The Enemy Within” presented many problems with canon to say the least but The Doctor coming out with this ‘revelation’ lead to fandom nearly imploding with rage. The implications of The Doctor not being entirely Time Lord were massive, how did he regenerate? How was he brought up Gallifrey if he was partially human? Who on Earth was his mother? The questions raised seemed endless, however a way out presented itself by dismissing the statement as being entirely factious. The Doctor, especially in his later incarnations, is a pretty sarcastic and the king of the wind up and as such the remark can be interpreted as affectionate or a joke. Just as the Eleventh Doctor’s remark to Clyde in The Sarah Jane Adventures episode “Death of the Doctor” that he can regenerate 507 times has been filed under “disregard as joke” by fandom so has The Doctor’s claim to half-humanity.

7) Time Lords only gain their second heart after their first regeneration.

When the first Doctor claims to Ian Chesterton that he is not from Earth, the long suffering science teacher puts his ear to the Doctors chest… and hears nothing unusual, the Doctor must only have one heart beating. We know from the third doctor that having two hearts is the norm for Time Lords, his medical tests during “Spearhead From Space” confirm it and many times since then it has been explicitly stated or shown, after all the seventh Doctor is killed because of Grace’s misunderstanding of his binary hearts. So something must change between the first and third Doctors, the most popular explanation is that a Time Lord only gains a second heart once they’ve regenerated for the first time.

6) Claire Bloom’s character in “The End of Time” is The Doctor’s mother.

The mystery of who exactly Claire Bloom’s character is in “The End of Time” will probably never be resolved on screen and as such the wild speculation as to her precise identity began almost as soon as the credits rolled on the episode. The most popular explanation amongst fans is that she is The Doctor’s mother, in his book “The Writers Tale” Russell T Davies stated that this was his thinking behind the character but he left it deliberately ambiguous. The tenth Doctor’s reaction to her certainly backs up the hypothesis but now RTD has left the series and he did not give an in-episode explanation she could be given any number of alternative identities. Other popular alternative identities include Romana, Susan, Susan’s mother (i.e. The Doctor’s biological daughter), Jenny or even Chancellor Flavia the former Time Lord President.

5) The Third Doctor has a prisoner tattoo

In the third Doctor’s first episode “Spearhead From Space” we are treated to the sight of the Doctor getting out of the shower, while he holding a towel a tattoo of a cobra can be seen on his right forearm (see picture above) in reality the tattoo was Jon Pertwee’s which he got during his days in the navy. No explanation was ever given on screen but the novel “Christmas on a Rational Planet” and fandom at large theorised that it was a criminal brand given to him by the Time Lords and that once they rescinded his exile they stopped it appearing on his next regeneration. A possible interesting (but quite tangential) moment in “The Doctor’s Wife” that could lend the theory further credence is that The Doctor’s fellow Time Lord The Corsair wears a tattoo on all his/her regenerations, a Oroborus, a snake eatings its own tail. When The Doctor discovers it on Auntie the tattoo is on the left arm, is it possible that The Corsair was also a criminal and first given that mark by the Time Lords?

4) The fifth Doctor is the final incarnation of the original Doctor. The Sixth Doctor is a reincarnation, and the beginning of a new 13 body lifecycle.

In the episode “The Brain of Morbius” The Doctor challenges the renegade Time Lord Morbius to an ancient, dangerous Time Lord challenge, a Mind Bending Contest (see picture above). They square up at the machine and The Doctor’s previous incarnations flash up on a screen, the third, the second, the first… and then an unfamiliar face flashes up, then another and another as Morbius screams “back! Back through your past!” Eight in all flash by. If all those faces were previous Doctors then that means that the person who we all thought was the fourth Doctor is actually the twelfth! When the fifth Doctor (or should that be thirteenth?) regenerates he says “it feels different this time” and then transforms into the sixth Doctor… or begins a brand new lifecycle and is in fact the first Doctor… again. This theory has also been used to explain the sixth Doctor’s unhinged behavior and total confusion. This theory has been utterly debunked by virtually every other piece of Doctor Who canon, “The Brain of Morbius” was written some time before the 13 regeneration limit was established and the series (especially post 2005) has gone to great pains to establish that The Doctor we are watching is either the ninth, tenth or eleventh and that William Hartnell was the very first Doctor. The faces that we see in the mind bending machine have been explained away as being previous faces of Morbius and that he was just ranting when he said “how long have you lived?”… or was he?

3) The Time War was the cause of the 8th Doctor regenerating into the 9th.

This is an idea that has now been generally accepted into the canon, the tenth Doctor implies in “Journey’s End” that the ninth Doctor was “born into battle”, its easy to imagine the eighth Doctor sacrificing himself to time lock the Daleks and Time Lords and leaving an emotionally scarred, newly regenerated ninth Doctor to walk away. This is one of the theories that will probably be an accepted albeit unstated part of the canon until we get an alternative presented on screen.

2) Series 6b

This is the big one, the granddaddy of all fan theories, first raised by Paul Cornell, writer of Doctor Who novels, audio plays and episodes for the new series. It explains continuity discrepancies in the Second Doctor’s life as it expands on televised Doctor Who canon and places new adventures for the Second Doctor between The War Games and the first appearance of the Third Doctor at the start of Spearhead from Space. There are two continuity errors in “The Two Doctors” which can only explained by the existence of a series 6b where The Doctor was working for the Time Lords, firstly why the second Doctor and Jamie look visibly older and secondly why the Doctor had a remote controlled TARDIS which no other Doctor has had before or since. Despite series 6b being a neat explanation it also raises plenty of problems on its own if accepted as part of official canon.

1) The “Take 5” Theory.

This theory proposes that every incarnation of the Doctor is most like the incarnation that came five changes previously, so the sixth Doctor is like the first Doctor, the seventh is like the second, the eighth is like the third and so on. On the face of it this theory makes quite a lot of sense, for instance the seventh Doctor is a mysterious trickster of short stature who people constantly underestimate, quite like the second doctor. The theory seems especially convincing in the case of the tenth and fifth Doctors, just watch “Time Crash” which is essentially ten minute long proof of this theory in action! Unfortunately this theory hits a major roadblock in the fourth and ninth Doctors as the ninth Doctor could not be further removed from the fourth Doctor if you tried, I await the twelfth incarnation of the Doctor with baited breath, if only to see if they’re anything like the seventh Doctor…

Have you got any strange theories? What do you think of these ones? Let me know in the comments!


5 Responses to “Top Ten: 10 Mad Fan Theories (That Might Actually Be True)”

  1. Ardalyon said

    The Doctor’s regenerations are on a loop. The thirteenth Doctor will regenerate into the first!

  2. Mel1 said

    Hmmm, i wouldn’t say the 9th Doctor is that far detached from the 4th. They both have a quite a temper on them when they need it and they both have the same moody demeanor, especially the 4th Doctor in season 18.

    As for the War Chief, of course he’s the Master and i’ll always believe it.

  3. Alessandro said

    I fully subscribe to the way the 8th regenerated into the 9th and to the idea that the second heart grows at the first regeneration.
    As for the season 6B, it is just something more than fandom: it is endorsed even by the BBC on the official Doctor Who website. There you can find a much better reason why the series 6B is necessary for continuity: (1) how could Jamie know of the Time Lords when Jamie didn’t even know of the Time Lords until “The War Games”?; and (2) the Second Doctor was figuring out how to stay as hidden as possible from the Time Lords, yet we find him working for them!!!

    I don’t think it is necessary to admit the Doctor’s mother was human. She may as well have been a Time Lady turned into a human by the aid of a Chameleon Arch, more then sufficient to give a little bit of human traits to the Doctor. And we have witness by River Song that even half-timelords can regenerate though she didn’t grow a second heart.

    As for the Morbius episode, some tie-in materials explain that the FIRST Doctor may have been a reincarnation of somebody else (namely, the Other). This is a third way to explain out this continuity issue, though I don’t consider the Virgin New Adventures to be canonical in any way. Possibly Morbius was completely mad?

  4. John Miller said

    Great article, but sadly you left out my all-time favourite…The Two Doctors Theory(nothing to do with that Seasoin 22 serial)

    If Season 6B is true(and the above-mentioned serial would make it seem that it IS), this poses on obvious question…how could the Doctor be in his Season 6B travels and exiled on earth working for UNIT at the same time? Wouldn’t the Time Lords be able to know that he wasn’t exiled when he should be(he is visited by Time Lords early during his exile). Why are the Doctor’s memories full of goles, and often at odds with what we saw?Why wouldn’t Pertwee’s character have already known what was going to happen in the Three Doctors if he’s lived through it as Troughton’s Doctor? Actually, that’s more than one question!

    So here goes…the Doctor is Hartnell, then Troughton. At the end of the War games he is to be exiled to Earth with his appearance changed. However, at the same time certain missions must be undertaken(eg. The Two doctors again). In order to achieve this, the Time Lords wipe the memory of another Time lord, alter his appearance, brainwash him to think he’s The Doctor, and exile him to Earth. Meanwhile, the REAL Doctor is continuing on as a secret agent for the Time Lords. This also explains many seeming continuity errors in Three Doctors and Five Doctors(as well as many other comments and continuity errors!).

    The fake Doctor regenerates into his 12th incarnation(Tom Baker). In The Brain Of Morbius, Morbius drives Tom Baker back through, Pertwee, then two fake memories, then back through his real eight earlier incarnations. Morbius thinks he has won the mental duel, but Tom Baker’s REAL first two incarnations remain unseen. All the while The Doctor is continuing on in his second incarnation in other adventures, under the cover of secrecy.

    Believing he is THE Doctor, The peter Davison incarnation expects to still have eight incarnations left. When he dies however, he realises that something is definitely wrong. “It feels different this time… this death?” And then he dies. Meanwhile the REAL Doctor is teleported in, and is clearly bewildered, and paranoid. And who could blame him?

    Thus THE Doctor goes….Hartnelll…Troughton….(possible other incarnation or incarnations)….C. Baker…Mccoy etc.

  5. Andrew said

    There’s also the “Shalka Doctor is the Valeyard” one. Basically, the Valeyard is dark side of the Doctor between his twelfth and thirteenth incarnations. The Valeyard escapes the Matrix at the end of The Ultimate Foe and then,,,? What happened to him? We know both from Trial of a Time lord and He Jests At Scars that the Valeyard that the Valeyard is not evil per se, just a darker version of the Doctor himself, who thinks he could do a better job, In Scream of the Shalka he doesn’t say he’s the Ninth Doctor. He says that he’s “used up his nine lives”, the cat metaphor for at the end of his lives. Interesting that the Sixth Doctor had the cat motif. And he’s the one the Valeyard tried to get the lives from. Since the Valeyard is between the twelfth and thirteenth incarnations, he could easily regenerate, but only once, into a darker moodier Doctor, but one who still has the Doctor’s basic ideas of fighting what he perceives to be evil. The Time Lord responsible for foiling the Valeyard’s scheme was the Master. So what better way to get perceived revenge than having an android programmed with the Master’s memory/identity(got from the Matrix) trapped inside the Valeyard’s TARDIS, unable to leave and a permanent servant to the Doctor? At some point the Jayston Valeyard regenerates into his second(and final) incarnation Richard E. Grant’s ‘Doctor’. Did he survive the Time War? Possibly. Just like in Stargate where there are two stargates on the same world and you can’t dial one from the other, so the Doctor wouldn’t sense ANOTHER Time Lord, because in a sense it’s him himself. It would be great if in the 50th anniversary year, an episode could start with the TARDIS landing, the Shalka Doctor getting out, and the adventure continuing, until the reveal that it’s the Valeyard.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: